“Dispelling the Myth” Schools
Every year The Education Trust gives awards to schools that are succeeding in what it calls “Dispelling the Myth,” the myth in question being that schools cannot be expected to help most children who are poor, African American, or Latino meet meaningful academic standards.

The educators in the “Dispelling the Myth” schools believe right down to their toes that schools can and should be expected to help their kids achieve. It is an exhilarating experience to walk into one of these schools and to talk with the educators in them. They deal with the same kinds of issues that educators everywhere are dealing with: kids with limited vocabularies who watch too much television; parents whose experiences left them gun-shy about schools; teachers who arrive in the profession without knowing how to manage a classroom; and buses that don’t arrive on time. But they confront all those problems and more in a thoughtful way that allows them to help all or almost all of their students meet or exceed standards.

I wrote about some of the previous winners in “It’s Being Done”: Academic Success in Unexpected Schools and one of the conclusions I came to is that although getting the results they get is not easy, these schools demonstrate that it can be done.

I thought I would introduce you to this year’s award winners, because they are an inspiring bunch of schools. They’ll be formally announced next week, but let me tell you a little about them.
  • A small school in the Ozarks in a town where many adults failed to graduate from high school and very few went to college. Most people in the area get through the winter with the help of the gardens they plant in the spring, and the attitude of many parents toward the school is summed up in the words of one father: “The school’s okay, but it should have more sports.” Teachers say the school’s geographic isolation deepens their responsibility to introduce their students to the outside world and to prepare them for it by making them as academically accomplished as possible. It is only a small leap of the imagination to be reminded of stories of the rough-and-tumble frontier where the schoolmarm and schoolmaster were exemplars of learning and culture. This year the school’s literacy scores were among the highest in the state—a remarkable achievement for a school where about 80 percent of the students are low-income. Says one of the teachers: “We are dedicated to teaching not only whatever—because we could teach anything. We are dedicated to teaching to excellence.”
  • A suburban school that has been abandoned by its white, middle-class neighbors, some of whom tell the principal that their children have nothing in common with the Central American, Asian, and African immigrants who make up the majority of the student body. With about 80 percent of the students qualifying for the federal meal subsidy, and most speaking a language other than English at home, 100 percent of the sixth-grade students met the state’s standards for reading in 2008 and 96 percent met the state’s standards for math. That’s not all—about 70 percent exceeded the reading and math standards. Those scores don’t result from doing a lot of mindless test prep. Instead, the school’s faculty thinks deeply about what students need to know and then work hard to make sure they learn it. “This is a hard job,” says the principal, “but if you want to wake up knowing that you will make a difference, this is the place to teach.”
  • An urban charter middle school where all the students are either African American or Latino. Many of the students arrive two or more grade levels behind in reading and few arrive proficient. As one graduate remembers, “Reading wasn’t really my thing” when he first entered. After they finish eighth grade, all the students go to college preparatory high schools, some of them very selective. One teacher describes the school’s success as being based on “the passion of every single adult.” But the school doesn’t run on passion alone—teachers carefully study their state’s and other states’ standards, plan their instruction, and work together on lesson plans and identifying students who need additional help. One student says that before he entered, “I wasn’t sure I was going to make it.” After arriving at the school, he says, “I started believing I could.”
  • A school in the kind of rust-belt town where, a generation ago, “everybody’s father” worked at the mill but today is losing population and heart. Many such towns see academic achievement plummet as unemployment and poverty rises; in this town, academic achievement has steadily increased. The schools benefit from the fact that teachers across the district work together to develop common lesson plans within reading, math, social studies, and science curricula. The mantra the district lives by is, “systems elevate averages.” One school in particular is a standout, with just about every student meeting or exceeding state standards in reading, math, and science for the last several years. Says the principal: “Everybody tries to work together to do what’s best for students.”
That just gives a taste of these schools—once they’re announced, you will be able to read stories I’ve written about them on Ed Trust’s website. Anybody who’s really curious to hear faculty members describe what their schools do should think about coming to Washington, D.C., for the The Education Trust’s national conference from November 13-15, where they will be speaking.

Every year I am amazed at how different the schools we choose are and yet how consistent their underlying spirits. They are big and small; urban, suburban, and rural; integrated and racially isolated. But in each the faculty take seriously the need to connect with each individual student in their care and make sure all their students learn important things to prepare them for the rest of their lives. These educators are doing what too many dismiss as impossible—educating just about all students to a meaningful standard. I won’t say they make it look easy—it’s very clear they are working hard—but they make it look possible.

About the Author: Karin Chenoweth is a long-time education writer who currently writes for The Education Trust. She is the author of "It's Being Done": Academic Success in Unexpected Schools. From 1999 to 2004 she wrote a column on schools and education for The Washington Post, and before that was senior writer and executive editor of Black Issues in Higher Education (now Diverse).

Comments:

Nov 7, 2008 04:59 PM Karin,

It is so good to see this. Again and again, every day, every pundit who comments on the state of the nation says how awful schools are. There is a lot of bad schooling out there, but there are also the kinds of the places you profile. It does us no good to dismiss public education wholesale, and your examples remind us of that.

– Mike Rose

Nov 25, 2008 01:04 PM My concern is their/your measure of success. I know, you'll say that it's not all about the test scores (mindless test prep you say), but what of science and social studies. As a teacher in the same county, I know they've sacrificed content area subjects to achieve their goals. I find this problematic because proving that Title I students can read a test does not teach them conceptually about "Changes over time" or the impact of human culture on our society. I'm concerned about robbing Peter, to pay Paul.

– Michael Blume

Dec 9, 2008 03:56 PM Mike--Thanks.
Michael--not sure to which school you are referring to when you say you are in the same county. I agree that some schools have stopped teaching science and social studies, but that is not true of the schools I talk about above, which I can name now--Norfork Elementary in Norfork, Arkansas; Graham Road Elementary in Falls Church, Virginia., Roxbury Preparatory Charter School in Boston, Massachusetts., and Wells Elementary in Steubenville, Ohio. Two of the schools (Wells and Graham Road)also have a specific arts focus.

It's time for us as a nation to understand that teaching science, social studies, and the arts does not take away time from reading and writing but is in fact an integral part of reading and writing instruction.

Full profiles of these schools will be posted soon on the web site of The Education Trust, which has profiles of several other high-poverty high achieving schools.
http://www2.edtrust.org/EdTrust/Product+Catalog/main.htm#sp

These profiles examine the kinds of things successful schools do to ensure that all their children--including children who live in poverty and isolation--achieve at high levels.

Of course, I would be remiss in not mentioning that you could also read It's Being Done for more information as well.

– Karin Chenoweth

Oct 3, 2009 09:20 PM I found my way to this post after reading your article in the American Educator. I cannot wait to read your books. The most powerful element in the success of these schools is that the adults involved first chose to believe that all students can be successful. The moment we start to list reasons why they won't be we have stopped believing that they will be. Game over. The belief must come first. How can we convince the students if we do not believe it ourselves? And frankly, that belief is a simple choice....a decision to act as if it is true, despite messages in the system and in society to the contrary.

Thank you for the reminder.

Laurie
Hearts for Teaching

– Laurie Clarcq

Submit your comment

:
:  will not be published
:
The opinions expressed here do not reflect the opinions of the Harvard Education Publishing Group or the Harvard Graduate School of Education. Harvard Education Publishing Group is not responsible for the accuracy of any of the information supplied by guest bloggers.